How I give & receive design feedback
- Patrice Mondezie
- Apr 23, 2024
- 2 min read
Today, we're unpacking a topic that is as vital to our work as a detailed design brief or a trusty sketchpad - Feedback.
Yes, it can be a tough pill to swallow at times, but when given and received correctly, feedback becomes an invaluable tool in our design kit.
So, let's dive in, shall we?
The Art of Giving Feedback
I remember my early days as a designer, sitting in critique standups, struggling to articulate my thoughts on a colleague's design.
The fear of offending someone with my comments often left me tongue-tied.
Sounds familiar?
Well, I've learned a few things since then:
• Be Specific: Instead of saying "I don't like this", pinpoint exact elements and explain why they don't work.
For instance, "The text is difficult to read against the background color" is more helpful.
• Balance Positives with Negatives: Sandwich criticism between positive comments. It's not just a feel-good strategy – it also reinforces what works in the design.
• Provide Solutions: If you can, offer an alternative approach. Remember, constructive feedback is about building up, not tearing down.
• Stay Objective: Keep personal preferences out of the equation. Focus on how well the design meets the project's objectives.
Receiving Feedback Gracefully
On the flip side, as a new designer, I often took criticism of my designs to heart. It felt personal, and it hurt.
Over time, I realized that every piece of feedback, whether complimentary or critical, was a stepping stone to becoming a better designer.
Here's how you can handle critique like a pro:
• Don't Take It Personally: Remember, it's your design that's being critiqued, not you.
• Listen Actively: Resist the urge to defend your design immediately. Take time to understand the feedback.
• Ask Questions: If something is unclear, ask for clarification. It shows you're open to learning.
• Evaluate Feedback: Not all criticism is valid. Consider the source and the context before deciding to implement the changes.
Remember, fellow designers, feedback is a gift.
It provides an opportunity to see our work from a different perspective, pushes us out of our comfort zones, and nudges us towards growth.
So, the next time you're giving or receiving feedback, remember these tips and watch how they transform your design process.
Until next time, keep designing and growing!
✌🏾
Comments